When I Hit Cmd-Z One Too Many Times (rwblog S6E15)
Miyazaki and Allowing Artists To Make Bad Art
Earlier this year, Austin Kleon linked to an old BBC interview where an art critic argued that “artists must be allowed to make bad work”. I thought of this again while watching The Boy and the Heron, the new Miyazaki film.
I thought Boy and the Heron was decent but didn’t really match up to the heights of his career1. But that doesn’t stop Miyazaki! Despite statements to the contrary, he is reportedly not retiring and already started work on his next, “last” film. I find it pretty comforting that Miyazaki just keeps making films; even if his next film isn’t amazing, even if it’s his last last, we still have all the great films he made before. New films don’t (necessarily) detract from the experience of the previous films!
Somewhat related: It’s Not A Bad Restaurant, It’s A Bad Dish, which argues that we should think in terms of a bad dish instead of a bad restaurant, because maybe other dishes are good, then extends that to artists and their works.
Here’s a concept I thought of recently that I would love for someone else to build 🙂
Most text editors have an undo/redo functionality based on a stack of text edits per file. Make a change at the top followed by a change at the bottom, then undo twice, and both changes get undone.
But what if we had undo/redo based on a stack per region? For instance, in programming, we could have an undo/redo stack for each function block, say, or for regions defined by heuristics like “these two edits were very far apart”. Which stack you use could be defined by the current cursor position, so undoing would always undo something “near” you.
I thought of this because in programming we often end up with text files with many lines of code, and we end up changing code in different “regions” of a text file, like say changing the imports at the top of the file and the implementation in the middle of the file. It’s annoying to have to change context when I hit Cmd-Z one too many times 😞
Clearly there would be a lot of tough technical decisions, most obviously what happens when regions end up merged, which is why I don’t want to build this myself 🙂 git can sorta do this by being very carefully about how you stage patches, but that isn’t well supported by most tooling. I wonder if something like this exists anywhere?
I subscribe to too many newsletters, so for the new year I’m doing a mini subscription purge. I am surprised just how many I actually subscribe to! Anyway, if you, like me, read too much, you may find it a helpful time to start purging.
My favorites are Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke, and Kiki’s Delivery Service, although I liked Castle in the Sky too. I’ve never actually seen Porco Rosso or Nausicaa, though! As a side note, I have a working theory that people (that like Miyazaki films) can either like Kiki’s or Howl’s but not both. ↩